MG Comet EV vs Tata Punch EV - Which One Should You Buy
MG Comet EV vs Tata Punch EV Comparison at CarHP India. Compare MG Comet EV and Tata Punch EV Prices, Mileage, Features, Specs, Colours and much more.
The MG Comet EV Executive comes in 6 variants. The selected variant is priced at ₹7.50 Lakh. The cheapest variant, Executive, costs ₹7.50 Lakh, while the top-end variant, Exclusive, is priced at ₹9.56 Lakh. The Tata Punch EV Smart comes in 20 variants. The selected variant is priced at ₹9.99 Lakh. The cheapest variant, Smart, costs ₹9.99 Lakh, while the top-end variant, Empowered Plus S LR AC FC, is priced at ₹14.44 Lakh.
| Specification | MG Comet EV | Tata Punch EV | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | ₹7.50 Lakh | ₹9.99 Lakh | |
| Engine | Electric | Electric | |
| Motor | Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor | Permanent magnet synchronous motor (PMSM) | |
| Range | 230 km | 315 km | |
| Transmission | 1-Speed | Single Speed |
Pros & Cons
MG Comet EV
- Priced incredibly low at ₹4.99 lakh (ex-showroom), making it India’s cheapest electric car
- Compact size and 4.2-meter turning radius make it perfect for tight urban spaces
- Spacious 350-liter boot for its size—good for groceries or small luggage
- Lifetime battery warranty provides peace of mind for long-term ownership
- Impressive torque (110 Nm) for quick city sprints
- Real-world range of 180-200 km suits most daily commutes
Tata Punch EV
- Available with two practical range options
- Feature-rich cabin, especially in higher trims, with digital screens
- Practical 366-liter boot space for its size
- Comfortable ride quality suitable for city driving
- High ground clearance for tackling various road conditions
- Expected strong safety credentials
Engine and Performance
The MG Comet EV Executive is powered by a electric motor producing a maximum power of 41.42bhp and maximum torque of 110Nm. This car has a charging time of 3.3KW 7H (0-100%). The Tata Punch EV Smart is powered by a electric motor producing a maximum power of 80.46bhp and maximum torque of 114Nm. This car has a charging time of 3.6H 3.3 kW (10-100%).
The MG Comet EV Executive is powered by a electric motor producing a maximum power of 41.42bhp and maximum torque of 110Nm. This car has a charging time of 3.3KW 7H (0-100%). The Tata Punch EV Smart is powered by a electric motor producing a maximum power of 80.46bhp and maximum torque of 114Nm. This car has a charging time of 3.6H 3.3 kW (10-100%).
| Feature | MG Comet EV (Executive) | Tata Punch EV (Smart) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Battery capacity | 17.3 kWh | 25 kWh | |
| Battery saver | - | ||
| Charger type | - | 3.3 kW AC Charger Box | |
| Charging options | - | 3.3 kW AC Charger Box | 7.2 kW AC Fast Charger | DC Fast Charger | |
| Charging port | CCS-II | CCS-II |
The MG Comet EV Executive is powered by a electric motor producing a maximum power of 41.42bhp and maximum torque of 110Nm. This car has a charging time of 3.3KW 7H (0-100%). The Tata Punch EV Smart is powered by a electric motor producing a maximum power of 80.46bhp and maximum torque of 114Nm. This car has a charging time of 3.6H 3.3 kW (10-100%).
The MG Comet EV Executive is powered by a electric motor producing a maximum power of 41.42bhp and maximum torque of 110Nm. This car has a charging time of 3.3KW 7H (0-100%). The Tata Punch EV Smart is powered by a electric motor producing a maximum power of 80.46bhp and maximum torque of 114Nm. This car has a charging time of 3.6H 3.3 kW (10-100%).
Fuel Specifications
The MG Comet EV Executive runs on electricity and achieves a maximum range of 230 km. The Tata Punch EV Smart runs on electricity and achieves a maximum range of 315 km.
The MG Comet EV Executive runs on electricity and achieves a maximum range of 230 km. The Tata Punch EV Smart runs on electricity and achieves a maximum range of 315 km.
| Feature | MG Comet EV (Executive) | Tata Punch EV (Smart) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Battery type | Lithium-Ion | Lithium-Ion | |
| Emission norm compliance | ZEV | ZEV | |
| Fuel type | Electric | Electric | |
| Max range | 230 km | 315 km | |
| Range tested | 182 | - |
The MG Comet EV Executive runs on electricity and achieves a maximum range of 230 km. The Tata Punch EV Smart runs on electricity and achieves a maximum range of 315 km.
The MG Comet EV Executive runs on electricity and achieves a maximum range of 230 km. The Tata Punch EV Smart runs on electricity and achieves a maximum range of 315 km.
Dimensions and Design
The MG Comet EV Executive has a height of 1640 mm, length measures 2974 mm, width is 1505 mm. The Tata Punch EV Smart has a height of 1633 mm, length measures 3857 mm, width is 1742 mm.
The MG Comet EV Executive has a height of 1640 mm, length measures 2974 mm, width is 1505 mm. The Tata Punch EV Smart has a height of 1633 mm, length measures 3857 mm, width is 1742 mm.
| Feature | MG Comet EV (Executive) | Tata Punch EV (Smart) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Body type | Hatchback | SUV | |
| Ground clearance | - | 190 mm | |
| Height | 1640 mm | 1633 mm | |
| Length | 2974 mm | 3857 mm | |
| Wheelbase | 2010 mm | 2445 mm |
The MG Comet EV Executive has a height of 1640 mm, length measures 2974 mm, width is 1505 mm. The Tata Punch EV Smart has a height of 1633 mm, length measures 3857 mm, width is 1742 mm.
The MG Comet EV Executive has a height of 1640 mm, length measures 2974 mm, width is 1505 mm. The Tata Punch EV Smart has a height of 1633 mm, length measures 3857 mm, width is 1742 mm.
Interior Specifications
The Tata Punch EV Smart offers a boot space of 366 Litres.
The Tata Punch EV Smart offers a boot space of 366 Litres.
| Feature | MG Comet EV (Executive) | Tata Punch EV (Smart) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Boot space | - | 366 Litres | |
| No of doors | 2 | 5 | |
| Seating capacity | 4 | 5 |
The Tata Punch EV Smart offers a boot space of 366 Litres.
The Tata Punch EV Smart offers a boot space of 366 Litres.
Wheels & Tires
The MG Comet EV Executive offers wheel and tyre features such as Wheel Covers. MG Comet EV Executive runs on tyres sized 145/70 R12. The Tata Punch EV Smart offers wheel and tyre features such as Wheel Covers. Tata Punch EV Smart runs on tyres sized 185/70 R15.
The MG Comet EV Executive offers wheel and tyre features such as Wheel Covers. MG Comet EV Executive runs on tyres sized 145/70 R12. The Tata Punch EV Smart offers wheel and tyre features such as Wheel Covers. Tata Punch EV Smart runs on tyres sized 185/70 R15.
| Feature | MG Comet EV (Executive) | Tata Punch EV (Smart) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Alloy wheels | - | ||
| Front track | - | 1595 mm | |
| Tyre size | 145/70 R12 | 185/70 R15 | |
| Tyre type | Radial Tubeless | Low rolling resistance | |
| Wheel covers |
The MG Comet EV Executive offers wheel and tyre features such as Wheel Covers. MG Comet EV Executive runs on tyres sized 145/70 R12. The Tata Punch EV Smart offers wheel and tyre features such as Wheel Covers. Tata Punch EV Smart runs on tyres sized 185/70 R15.
The MG Comet EV Executive offers wheel and tyre features such as Wheel Covers. MG Comet EV Executive runs on tyres sized 145/70 R12. The Tata Punch EV Smart offers wheel and tyre features such as Wheel Covers. Tata Punch EV Smart runs on tyres sized 185/70 R15.
Suspension, Brakes & Steering
The MG Comet EV Executive uses a MacPherson Strut suspension setup at the front and a Multi-link suspension at the back for balanced comfort and stability. Braking duties are handled by Disc at the front and Drum at the rear. The Tata Punch EV Smart uses a MacPherson Strut suspension setup at the front and a Rear twist beam at the back for balanced comfort and stability. Braking duties are handled by Disc at the front and Drum at the rear.
The MG Comet EV Executive uses a MacPherson Strut suspension setup at the front and a Multi-link suspension at the back for balanced comfort and stability. Braking duties are handled by Disc at the front and Drum at the rear. The Tata Punch EV Smart uses a MacPherson Strut suspension setup at the front and a Rear twist beam at the back for balanced comfort and stability. Braking duties are handled by Disc at the front and Drum at the rear.
| Feature | MG Comet EV (Executive) | Tata Punch EV (Smart) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Front brake type | Disc | Disc | |
| Front suspension | MacPherson Strut suspension | MacPherson Strut suspension | |
| Rear brake type | Drum | Drum | |
| Rear suspension | Multi-link suspension | Rear twist beam | |
| Steering type | Electric | Electric |
The MG Comet EV Executive uses a MacPherson Strut suspension setup at the front and a Multi-link suspension at the back for balanced comfort and stability. Braking duties are handled by Disc at the front and Drum at the rear. The Tata Punch EV Smart uses a MacPherson Strut suspension setup at the front and a Rear twist beam at the back for balanced comfort and stability. Braking duties are handled by Disc at the front and Drum at the rear.
The MG Comet EV Executive uses a MacPherson Strut suspension setup at the front and a Multi-link suspension at the back for balanced comfort and stability. Braking duties are handled by Disc at the front and Drum at the rear. The Tata Punch EV Smart uses a MacPherson Strut suspension setup at the front and a Rear twist beam at the back for balanced comfort and stability. Braking duties are handled by Disc at the front and Drum at the rear.
Safety Features
The MG Comet EV Executive comes equipped with safety features like Driver Airbag, Seat Belt Warning, Anti Lock Braking System Abs, Central Locking, Passenger Airbag, and and many more. The Tata Punch EV Smart comes equipped with safety features like Hill Assist, Driver Airbag, Side Airbag, Seat Belt Warning, Anti Lock Braking System Abs, and and many more.
The MG Comet EV Executive comes equipped with safety features like Driver Airbag, Seat Belt Warning, Anti Lock Braking System Abs, Central Locking, Passenger Airbag, and and many more. The Tata Punch EV Smart comes equipped with safety features like Hill Assist, Driver Airbag, Side Airbag, Seat Belt Warning, Anti Lock Braking System Abs, and and many more.
| Feature | MG Comet EV (Executive) | Tata Punch EV (Smart) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 360 view camera | - | ||
| Adaptive cruise control | - | ||
| Anti-lock Braking System ABS | |||
| Anti theft alarm | - | ||
| Anti theft device | - |
The MG Comet EV Executive comes equipped with safety features like Driver Airbag, Seat Belt Warning, Anti Lock Braking System Abs, Central Locking, Passenger Airbag, and and many more. The Tata Punch EV Smart comes equipped with safety features like Hill Assist, Driver Airbag, Side Airbag, Seat Belt Warning, Anti Lock Braking System Abs, and and many more.
The MG Comet EV Executive comes equipped with safety features like Driver Airbag, Seat Belt Warning, Anti Lock Braking System Abs, Central Locking, Passenger Airbag, and and many more. The Tata Punch EV Smart comes equipped with safety features like Hill Assist, Driver Airbag, Side Airbag, Seat Belt Warning, Anti Lock Braking System Abs, and and many more.
Interior Features
The MG Comet EV Executive includes interior features such as Dual Tone Dashboard.
The MG Comet EV Executive includes interior features such as Dual Tone Dashboard.
| Feature | MG Comet EV (Executive) | Tata Punch EV (Smart) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Additional features | Basic Audio, Bluetooth Music & Calling | ||
| Digital cluster | Embedded LCD Screen | - | |
| Dual tone dashboard | - | ||
| Leather wrap gear shift selector | - | ||
| Leather wrapped steering wheel | - |
The MG Comet EV Executive includes interior features such as Dual Tone Dashboard.
The MG Comet EV Executive includes interior features such as Dual Tone Dashboard.
Comfort & Convenience
For comfort, the MG Comet EV Executive offers Power Steering, Air Conditioner, Heater, Accessory Power Outlet, Keyless Entry, and and many more. For comfort, the Tata Punch EV Smart offers Adjustable Headrest, Air Quality Control, Automatic Climate Control, Height Adjustable Driver Seat, Power Steering, and and many more.
For comfort, the MG Comet EV Executive offers Power Steering, Air Conditioner, Heater, Accessory Power Outlet, Keyless Entry, and and many more. For comfort, the Tata Punch EV Smart offers Adjustable Headrest, Air Quality Control, Automatic Climate Control, Height Adjustable Driver Seat, Power Steering, and and many more.
| Feature | MG Comet EV (Executive) | Tata Punch EV (Smart) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Accessory power outlet | |||
| Adjustable headrest | - | ||
| Adjustable steering | - | ||
| Air conditioner | |||
| Air quality control | - |
For comfort, the MG Comet EV Executive offers Power Steering, Air Conditioner, Heater, Accessory Power Outlet, Keyless Entry, and and many more. For comfort, the Tata Punch EV Smart offers Adjustable Headrest, Air Quality Control, Automatic Climate Control, Height Adjustable Driver Seat, Power Steering, and and many more.
For comfort, the MG Comet EV Executive offers Power Steering, Air Conditioner, Heater, Accessory Power Outlet, Keyless Entry, and and many more. For comfort, the Tata Punch EV Smart offers Adjustable Headrest, Air Quality Control, Automatic Climate Control, Height Adjustable Driver Seat, Power Steering, and and many more.
Infotainment Features
In terms of infotainment, the MG Comet EV Executive offers Multi Function Steering Wheel, Radio, Bluetooth Connectivity, and Digital Odometer. In terms of infotainment, the Tata Punch EV Smart offers Smartwatch App, Integrated Antenna, and Digital Odometer.
In terms of infotainment, the MG Comet EV Executive offers Multi Function Steering Wheel, Radio, Bluetooth Connectivity, and Digital Odometer. In terms of infotainment, the Tata Punch EV Smart offers Smartwatch App, Integrated Antenna, and Digital Odometer.
| Feature | MG Comet EV (Executive) | Tata Punch EV (Smart) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Android auto | |||
| Apple carplay | |||
| Bluetooth connectivity | |||
| Digital car key | - | ||
| Digital cluster size | 7 Inch | - |
In terms of infotainment, the MG Comet EV Executive offers Multi Function Steering Wheel, Radio, Bluetooth Connectivity, and Digital Odometer. In terms of infotainment, the Tata Punch EV Smart offers Smartwatch App, Integrated Antenna, and Digital Odometer.
In terms of infotainment, the MG Comet EV Executive offers Multi Function Steering Wheel, Radio, Bluetooth Connectivity, and Digital Odometer. In terms of infotainment, the Tata Punch EV Smart offers Smartwatch App, Integrated Antenna, and Digital Odometer.
Select Car
Select your city
Popular Cities
