MG Comet EV vs Tata Punch EV - Which One Should You Buy

MG Comet EV vs Tata Punch EV Comparison at CarHP India. Compare MG Comet EV and Tata Punch EV Prices, Mileage, Features, Specs, Colours and much more.

Here is the detailed comparison of MG Comet EV vs Tata Punch EV across key factors such as engine performance, mileage, features, space, safety, and pricing.

Price
MG Comet EV
₹7.36 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.99 Lakh
Engine
MG Comet EV
Electric
Tata Punch EV
Electric
Motor
MG Comet EV
Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor
Tata Punch EV
Permanent magnet synchronous motor (PMSM)
Range
MG Comet EV
230 km
Tata Punch EV
315 km
Transmission
MG Comet EV
1-Speed
Tata Punch EV
Single Speed
MG Comet EV
MG Comet EV

Executive

Rs 7.36 Lakh

Tata Punch EV
Tata Punch EV

Smart

Rs 9.99 Lakh

Price Comparison

Price
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
7.36 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
9.99 Lakh

Engine and Performance

Battery capacity
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
17.3 kWh
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
25 kWh
Battery saver
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Charger type
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
3.3 kW AC Charger Box
Charging options
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
3.3 kW AC Charger Box | 7.2 kW AC Fast Charger | DC Fast Charger
Charging port
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
CCS-II
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
CCS-II
Charging time
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
3.3KW 7H (0-100%)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
3.6H 3.3 kW (10-100%)
Charging Time 15A Plug Point
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
9.4H (10% to 100%)
Charging time 50 kw dc fast charger
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
56 Min (10% to 80%)
Charging Time 7.2 kW AC Fast Charger
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
3.6H (10% to 100%)
Charging Time AC
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
3.6H 3.3 kW (10-100%)
Charging Time DC
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
56 Min-50 kW(10-80%)
Drive type
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
RWD
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
FWD
Engine start stop button
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Fast charging
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Gearbox
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
1-Speed
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Single Speed
Max power
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
41.42bhp
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
80.46bhp
Max torque
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
110Nm
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
114Nm
Motor power
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
41.42 kW
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
60 kW
Motor type
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Permanent magnet synchronous motor (PMSM)
Regenerative braking
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Regenerative braking levels
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
4
Transmission type
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Automatic
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Automatic

Fuel Specifications

Battery type
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Lithium-Ion
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Lithium-Ion
Emission norm compliance
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
ZEV
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
ZEV
Fuel type
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Electric
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Electric
Max range
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
230 km
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
315 km
Range tested
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
182
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
-

Dimensions and Design

Body type
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Hatchback
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
SUV
Ground clearance
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
190
Height
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
1640 mm
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
1633 mm
Length
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
2974 mm
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
3857 mm
Wheelbase
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
2010
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
2445
Width
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
1505 mm
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
1742 mm

Interior Specifications

Boot space
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
366 Litres
No of doors
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
2
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
5
Seating capacity
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
4
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
5

Wheels & Tires

Alloy wheels
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Front track
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
1595 mm
Tyre size
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
145/70 R12
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
185/70 R15
Tyre type
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Radial Tubeless
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Low rolling resistance
Wheel covers
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Wheel size
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
12 Inch
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
15 Inch

Suspension, Brakes & Steering

Front brake type
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Disc
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Disc
Front suspension
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
MacPherson Strut suspension
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
MacPherson Strut suspension
Rear brake type
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Drum
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Drum
Rear suspension
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Multi-link suspension
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Rear twist beam
Steering type
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Electric
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Electric
Turning radius
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
4 m
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
5 m

Safety Features

360 view camera
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Adaptive cruise control
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Anti-lock Braking System ABS
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Anti theft alarm
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
-
Anti theft device
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
-
Automatic emergency braking
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Blind spot collision avoidance assist
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Blind spot monitor
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Central locking
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Cornering foglamps
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Curtain airbag
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Day night rear view mirror
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Door ajar warning
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Driver airbag
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Driver attention warning
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
E call i call
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Electronic Brakeforce Distribution EBD
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Electronic Stability Control ESC
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Engine immobilizer
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
-
Engine start alarm
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
-
Forward collision warning
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Geo fence alert
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
-
Global NCAP Safety Rating
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
5
High beam assist
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Hill assist
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Hill descent control
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Impact sensing auto door unlock
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Isofix child seat mounts
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Lane departure prevention assist
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Lane departure warning
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Lane keep assist
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Leading vehicle departure alert
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
No of airbags
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
2
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
6
Oncoming lane mitigation
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Over speeding alert
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
-
Parking sensors
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Rear
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Rear
Passenger airbag
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Pretensioners force limiter seatbelts
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Driver and Passenger
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
-
Real time vehicle tracking
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
-
Rear camera
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Rear cross traffic alert
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Rear cross traffic collision avoidance assist
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Remote door lock unlock
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
-
Remote immobiliser
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
-
Road departure mitigation system
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
RSA Roadside Assistance
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Seat belt warning
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Side airbag
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Side airbag rear
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Speed alert
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
-
Speed assist system
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Speed sensing auto door lock
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Traffic sign recognition
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Tyre Pressure Monitoring System (TPMS)
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)

Interior Features

Additional features
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Basic Audio, Bluetooth Music & Calling
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Digital cluster
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Embedded LCD Screen
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
-
Dual tone dashboard
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
-
Leather wrap gear shift selector
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Leather wrapped steering wheel
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Upholstery
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Fabric
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Fabric

Comfort & Convenience

Accessory power outlet
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Adjustable headrest
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Adjustable steering
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
-
Air conditioner
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Air quality control
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Automatic climate control
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Automatic headlamps
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Cigarette lighter
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Cooled glovebox
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Cruise control
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Electric adjustable seats
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Engine start stop button
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Foldable rear seat
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
50:50 Split
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
-
Follow me home headlamps
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Gear shift indicator
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Glove box
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Glove box light
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Hands free tailgate
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Heated outside rear view mirror
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Heater
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Height adjustable driver seat
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Keyless entry
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
-
Luggage hook net
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Power steering
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Power windows front
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Rain sensing wiper
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Rear curtain
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Rear reading lamp
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Rear seat centre arm rest
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Rear seat headrest
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Rear window sunblind
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Rear windscreen sunblind
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Side stepper
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Vanity mirror
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
-
Ventilated seats
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)

Infotainment Features

Android auto
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Apple carplay
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Bluetooth connectivity
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Digital car key
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
-
Digital cluster size
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
7 Inch
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
-
Digital odometer
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Google alexa connectivity
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Hinglish voice commands
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
-
Integrated 2din audio
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Integrated antenna
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Live location
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
-
Multi function steering wheel
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
-
No of speakers
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
2
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
-
Over the air ota updates
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
-
Radio
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Smartwatch app
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Speakers
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Touchscreen
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
USB Charger
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Front
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
-
USB Ports
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
3
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
Voice commands
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
-
Wi-Fi Connectivity
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
-
Wireless phone charging
MG Comet EV
(Executive)
-
Tata Punch EV
(Smart)
MG Comet EV
MG Comet EV

Executive

7.36 Lakh

Tata Punch EV
Tata Punch EV

Smart

9.99 Lakh

+

Add Car