MG Comet EV vs Tata Punch EV - Which One Should You Buy

MG Comet EV vs Tata Punch EV Comparison at CarHP India. Compare MG Comet EV and Tata Punch EV Prices, Mileage, Features, Specs, Colours and much more.

The MG Comet EV comes in 7 variants. The selected variant is priced at ₹7.50 Lakh. The cheapest variant, Executive, costs ₹7.50 Lakh, while the top-end variant, 100 Year Limited Edition, is priced at ₹9.84 Lakh. The Tata Punch EV comes in 20 variants. The selected variant is priced at ₹9.99 Lakh. The cheapest variant, Smart, costs ₹9.99 Lakh, while the top-end variant, Empowered Plus S LR AC FC, is priced at ₹14.44 Lakh.

Specification	MG Comet EV	Tata Punch EV
Price	₹7.50 Lakh	₹9.99 Lakh
Engine	Electric	Electric
Motor	Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor	Permanent magnet synchronous motor (PMSM)
Range	230 km	315 km
Transmission	1-Speed	Single Speed

Price

₹7.50 Lakh

₹9.99 Lakh

Engine

Electric

Motor

Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor

Permanent magnet synchronous motor (PMSM)

Range

230 km

315 km

Transmission

1-Speed

Single Speed

Highlight Differences

MG Comet EV

₹ 7.50 Lakh

Tata Punch EV

₹ 9.99 Lakh

Add Car

MG Comet EV

₹ 7.50 Lakh

Tata Punch EV

₹ 9.99 Lakh

Highlight Differences

Pros & Cons

MG Comet EV

Priced incredibly low at ₹4.99 lakh (ex-showroom), making it India’s cheapest electric car
Compact size and 4.2-meter turning radius make it perfect for tight urban spaces
Spacious 350-liter boot for its size—good for groceries or small luggage
Lifetime battery warranty provides peace of mind for long-term ownership
Impressive torque (110 Nm) for quick city sprints
Real-world range of 180-200 km suits most daily commutes

Tata Punch EV

Available with two practical range options
Feature-rich cabin, especially in higher trims, with digital screens
Practical 366-liter boot space for its size
Comfortable ride quality suitable for city driving
High ground clearance for tackling various road conditions
Expected strong safety credentials

Engine and Performance

The MG Comet EV Executive is powered by a electric motor producing a maximum power of 42bhp and maximum torque of 110Nm. This car has a charging time of 3.3KW 7H (0-100%). The Tata Punch EV Smart is powered by a electric motor producing a maximum power of 80.46bhp and maximum torque of 114Nm. This car has a charging time of 56 Min-50 kW(10-80%).

Feature	MG Comet EV (Executive)	Tata Punch EV (Smart)
Max Power	42bhp	80.46bhp
Max Torque	110Nm	114Nm
Battery Capacity	17.3 kWh kWh	25 kWh kWh
Battery Saver	-
Charger Type	-	3.3 kW AC Charger Box

Engine and Performance

Max Power

42bhp

80.46bhp

Max Torque

110Nm

114Nm

Battery Capacity

17.3 kWh kWh

25 kWh kWh

Battery Saver

Charger Type

3.3 kW AC Charger Box

Fuel Specifications

The MG Comet EV Executive runs on electricity and achieves a maximum range of 230 km. The Tata Punch EV Smart runs on electricity and achieves a maximum range of 315 km.

Feature	MG Comet EV (Executive)	Tata Punch EV (Smart)
Battery Type	Lithium-Ion	Lithium-Ion
Emission Norm Compliance	ZEV	ZEV
Fuel Type	Electric	Electric
Max Range	230 km	315 km
Range Tested	182	-

Fuel Specifications

The MG Comet EV Executive runs on electricity and achieves a maximum range of 230 km. The Tata Punch EV Smart runs on electricity and achieves a maximum range of 315 km.

Battery Type

Lithium-Ion

Emission Norm Compliance

ZEV

Fuel Type

Electric

Max Range

230 km

315 km

Range Tested

182

Dimensions and Design

The MG Comet EV Executive has a height of 1640 mm, length measures 2974 mm, width is 1505 mm. The Tata Punch EV Smart has a height of 1633 mm, length measures 3857 mm, width is 1742 mm.

Feature	MG Comet EV (Executive)	Tata Punch EV (Smart)
Body Type	Hatchback	SUV
Ground Clearance	-	190 mm
Height	1640 mm	1633 mm
Length	2974 mm	3857 mm
Wheelbase	2010 mm	2445 mm

Dimensions and Design

The MG Comet EV Executive has a height of 1640 mm, length measures 2974 mm, width is 1505 mm. The Tata Punch EV Smart has a height of 1633 mm, length measures 3857 mm, width is 1742 mm.

Body Type

Hatchback

SUV

Ground Clearance

190 mm

Height

1640 mm

1633 mm

Length

2974 mm

3857 mm

Wheelbase

2010 mm

2445 mm

Interior Specifications

The MG Comet EV Executive offers a boot space of 350 Litres. The Tata Punch EV Smart offers a boot space of 366 Litres.

Feature	MG Comet EV (Executive)	Tata Punch EV (Smart)
Boot Space	350 Litres	366 Litres
No. of Doors	2	5
Seating Capacity	4	5

Interior Specifications

The MG Comet EV Executive offers a boot space of 350 Litres. The Tata Punch EV Smart offers a boot space of 366 Litres.

Boot Space

350 Litres

366 Litres

No. of Doors

Seating Capacity

Wheels & Tires

The MG Comet EV Executive offers wheel and tyre features such as Wheel Covers. MG Comet EV Executive runs on tyres sized 145/70 R12. The Tata Punch EV Smart offers wheel and tyre features such as Wheel Covers. Tata Punch EV Smart runs on tyres sized 185/70 R15.

Feature	MG Comet EV (Executive)	Tata Punch EV (Smart)
Alloy Wheels	-
Tyre Size	145/70 R12	185/70 R15
Tyre Type	Radial Tubeless	Low rolling resistance
Wheel Covers
Wheel Size	12 Inch	15 Inch

Wheels & Tires

Alloy Wheels

Tyre Size

145/70 R12

185/70 R15

Tyre Type

Radial Tubeless

Low rolling resistance

Wheel Covers

Wheel Size

12 Inch

15 Inch

Suspension, Brakes & Steering

The MG Comet EV Executive uses a MacPherson Strut suspension setup at the front and a Multi-link suspension at the back for balanced comfort and stability. Braking duties are handled by Disc at the front and Drum at the rear. The Tata Punch EV Smart uses a MacPherson Strut suspension setup at the front and a Rear twist beam at the back for balanced comfort and stability. Braking duties are handled by Disc at the front and Drum at the rear.

Feature	MG Comet EV (Executive)	Tata Punch EV (Smart)
Front Brake Type	Disc	Disc
Front Suspension	MacPherson Strut suspension	MacPherson Strut suspension
Rear Brake Type	Drum	Drum
Rear Suspension	Multi-link suspension	Rear twist beam
Steering Type	Electric	Electric

Suspension, Brakes & Steering

Front Brake Type

Disc

Front Suspension

MacPherson Strut suspension

Rear Brake Type

Drum

Rear Suspension

Multi-link suspension

Rear twist beam

Steering Type

Electric

Safety Features

The MG Comet EV Executive comes equipped with safety features like Driver Airbag, Seat Belt Warning, Anti Lock Braking System Abs, Central Locking, Passenger Airbag, and and many more. The Tata Punch EV Smart comes equipped with safety features like Hill Assist, Driver Airbag, Side Airbag, Seat Belt Warning, Anti Lock Braking System Abs, and and many more.

Feature	MG Comet EV (Executive)	Tata Punch EV (Smart)
360 View Camera	-
Adaptive Cruise Control	-
Anti Lock Braking System Abs
Anti Theft Alarm		-
Anti Theft Device		-

Safety Features

360 View Camera

Adaptive Cruise Control

Anti Lock Braking System Abs

Anti Theft Alarm

Anti Theft Device

Interior Features

The MG Comet EV Executive includes interior features such as Dual Tone Dashboard. The Tata Punch EV Smart includes interior features such as Tachometer.

Feature	MG Comet EV (Executive)	Tata Punch EV (Smart)
Digital Cluster	Embedded LCD Screen
Dual Tone Dashboard		-
Leather Wrap Gear Shift Selector	-
Tachometer	-
Upholstery	Fabric	Fabric

Interior Features

The MG Comet EV Executive includes interior features such as Dual Tone Dashboard. The Tata Punch EV Smart includes interior features such as Tachometer.

Digital Cluster

Embedded LCD Screen

Dual Tone Dashboard

Leather Wrap Gear Shift Selector

Tachometer

Upholstery

Fabric

Comfort & Convenience

For comfort, the MG Comet EV Executive offers Power Steering, Air Conditioner, Heater, Accessory Power Outlet, Keyless Entry, and and many more. For comfort, the Tata Punch EV Smart offers Adjustable Headrest, Air Quality Control, Automatic Climate Control, Height Adjustable Driver Seat, Power Steering, and and many more.

Feature	MG Comet EV (Executive)	Tata Punch EV (Smart)
Accessory Power Outlet
Adjustable Headrest	-
Adjustable Steering		Height only
Air Conditioner
Air Quality Control	-

Comfort & Convenience

Accessory Power Outlet

Adjustable Headrest

Adjustable Steering

Height only

Air Conditioner

Air Quality Control

Infotainment Features

In terms of infotainment, the MG Comet EV Executive offers Radio, Bluetooth Connectivity, and Digital Odometer. In terms of infotainment, the Tata Punch EV Smart offers Smartwatch App and Integrated Antenna.