MG Comet EV vs Tata Punch EV - Which One Should You Buy
MG Comet EV vs Tata Punch EV Comparison at CarHP India. Compare MG Comet EV and Tata Punch EV Prices, Mileage, Features, Specs, Colours and much more.
Here is the detailed comparison of MG Comet EV vs Tata Punch EV across key factors such as engine performance, mileage, features, space, safety, and pricing.
| Specification | MG Comet EV | Tata Punch EV | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | ₹7.36 Lakh | ₹9.99 Lakh | |
| Engine | Electric | Electric | |
| Motor | Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor | Permanent magnet synchronous motor (PMSM) | |
| Range | 230 km | 315 km | |
| Transmission | 1-Speed | Single Speed |
Price
₹7.36 Lakh
₹9.99 Lakh
Engine
Electric
Electric
Motor
Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor
Permanent magnet synchronous motor (PMSM)
Range
230 km
315 km
Transmission
1-Speed
Single Speed
Engine and Performance
| Feature | MG Comet EV (Executive) | Tata Punch EV (Smart) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Battery capacity | 17.3 kWh | 25 kWh | |
| Battery saver | - | ||
| Charger type | - | 3.3 kW AC Charger Box | |
| Charging options | - | 3.3 kW AC Charger Box | 7.2 kW AC Fast Charger | DC Fast Charger | |
| Charging port | CCS-II | CCS-II | |
| Charging time | 3.3KW 7H (0-100%) | 3.6H 3.3 kW (10-100%) | |
| Charging Time 15A Plug Point | - | 9.4H (10% to 100%) | |
| Charging time 50 kw dc fast charger | - | 56 Min (10% to 80%) | |
| Charging Time 7.2 kW AC Fast Charger | - | 3.6H (10% to 100%) | |
| Charging Time AC | - | 3.6H 3.3 kW (10-100%) | |
| Charging Time DC | - | 56 Min-50 kW(10-80%) | |
| Drive type | RWD | FWD | |
| Engine start stop button | |||
| Fast charging | |||
| Gearbox | 1-Speed | Single Speed | |
| Max power | 41.42bhp | 80.46bhp | |
| Max torque | 110Nm | 114Nm | |
| Motor power | 41.42 kW | 60 kW | |
| Motor type | Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor | Permanent magnet synchronous motor (PMSM) | |
| Regenerative braking | - | ||
| Regenerative braking levels | - | 4 | |
| Transmission type | Automatic | Automatic |
Engine and Performance
Battery capacity
17.3 kWh
25 kWh
Battery saver
-
Charger type
-
3.3 kW AC Charger Box
Charging options
-
3.3 kW AC Charger Box | 7.2 kW AC Fast Charger | DC Fast Charger
Charging port
CCS-II
CCS-II
Charging time
3.3KW 7H (0-100%)
3.6H 3.3 kW (10-100%)
Charging Time 15A Plug Point
-
9.4H (10% to 100%)
Charging time 50 kw dc fast charger
-
56 Min (10% to 80%)
Charging Time 7.2 kW AC Fast Charger
-
3.6H (10% to 100%)
Charging Time AC
-
3.6H 3.3 kW (10-100%)
Charging Time DC
-
56 Min-50 kW(10-80%)
Drive type
RWD
FWD
Engine start stop button
Fast charging
Gearbox
1-Speed
Single Speed
Max power
41.42bhp
80.46bhp
Max torque
110Nm
114Nm
Motor power
41.42 kW
60 kW
Motor type
Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor
Permanent magnet synchronous motor (PMSM)
Regenerative braking
-
Regenerative braking levels
-
4
Transmission type
Automatic
Automatic
Fuel Specifications
| Feature | MG Comet EV (Executive) | Tata Punch EV (Smart) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Battery type | Lithium-Ion | Lithium-Ion | |
| Emission norm compliance | ZEV | ZEV | |
| Fuel type | Electric | Electric | |
| Max range | 230 km | 315 km | |
| Range tested | 182 | - |
Fuel Specifications
Battery type
Lithium-Ion
Lithium-Ion
Emission norm compliance
ZEV
ZEV
Fuel type
Electric
Electric
Max range
230 km
315 km
Range tested
182
-
Dimensions and Design
| Feature | MG Comet EV (Executive) | Tata Punch EV (Smart) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Body type | Hatchback | SUV | |
| Ground clearance | - | 190 mm | |
| Height | 1640 mm | 1633 mm | |
| Length | 2974 mm | 3857 mm | |
| Wheelbase | 2010 mm | 2445 mm | |
| Width | 1505 mm | 1742 mm |
Dimensions and Design
Body type
Hatchback
SUV
Ground clearance
-
190 mm
Height
1640 mm
1633 mm
Length
2974 mm
3857 mm
Wheelbase
2010 mm
2445 mm
Width
1505 mm
1742 mm
Interior Specifications
| Feature | MG Comet EV (Executive) | Tata Punch EV (Smart) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Boot space | - | 366 Litres | |
| No of doors | 2 | 5 | |
| Seating capacity | 4 | 5 |
Interior Specifications
Boot space
-
366 Litres
No of doors
2
5
Seating capacity
4
5
Wheels & Tires
| Feature | MG Comet EV (Executive) | Tata Punch EV (Smart) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Alloy wheels | - | ||
| Front track | - | 1595 mm | |
| Tyre size | 145/70 R12 | 185/70 R15 | |
| Tyre type | Radial Tubeless | Low rolling resistance | |
| Wheel covers | |||
| Wheel size | 12 Inch | 15 Inch |
Wheels & Tires
Alloy wheels
-
Front track
-
1595 mm
Tyre size
145/70 R12
185/70 R15
Tyre type
Radial Tubeless
Low rolling resistance
Wheel covers
Wheel size
12 Inch
15 Inch
Suspension, Brakes & Steering
| Feature | MG Comet EV (Executive) | Tata Punch EV (Smart) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Front brake type | Disc | Disc | |
| Front suspension | MacPherson Strut suspension | MacPherson Strut suspension | |
| Rear brake type | Drum | Drum | |
| Rear suspension | Multi-link suspension | Rear twist beam | |
| Steering type | Electric | Electric | |
| Turning radius | 4 m | 5 m |
Suspension, Brakes & Steering
Front brake type
Disc
Disc
Front suspension
MacPherson Strut suspension
MacPherson Strut suspension
Rear brake type
Drum
Drum
Rear suspension
Multi-link suspension
Rear twist beam
Steering type
Electric
Electric
Turning radius
4 m
5 m
Safety Features
| Feature | MG Comet EV (Executive) | Tata Punch EV (Smart) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 360 view camera | - | ||
| Adaptive cruise control | - | ||
| Anti-lock Braking System ABS | |||
| Anti theft alarm | - | ||
| Anti theft device | - | ||
| Automatic emergency braking | - | ||
| Blind spot collision avoidance assist | - | ||
| Blind spot monitor | - | ||
| Central locking | |||
| Cornering foglamps | - | ||
| Curtain airbag | - | ||
| Day night rear view mirror | |||
| Door ajar warning | - | ||
| Driver airbag | |||
| Driver attention warning | - | ||
| E call i call | |||
| Electronic Brakeforce Distribution EBD | |||
| Electronic Stability Control ESC | |||
| Engine immobilizer | - | ||
| Engine start alarm | - | ||
| Forward collision warning | - | ||
| Geo fence alert | - | ||
| Global NCAP Safety Rating | - | 5 | |
| High beam assist | - | ||
| Hill assist | |||
| Hill descent control | - | ||
| Impact sensing auto door unlock | |||
| Isofix child seat mounts | |||
| Lane departure prevention assist | - | ||
| Lane departure warning | - | ||
| Lane keep assist | - | ||
| Leading vehicle departure alert | - | ||
| No of airbags | 2 | 6 | |
| Oncoming lane mitigation | - | ||
| Over speeding alert | - | ||
| Parking sensors | Rear | Rear | |
| Passenger airbag | |||
| Pretensioners force limiter seatbelts | Driver and Passenger | - | |
| Real time vehicle tracking | - | ||
| Rear camera | |||
| Rear cross traffic alert | - | ||
| Rear cross traffic collision avoidance assist | - | ||
| Remote door lock unlock | - | ||
| Remote immobiliser | - | ||
| Road departure mitigation system | - | ||
| RSA Roadside Assistance | - | ||
| Seat belt warning | |||
| Side airbag | - | ||
| Side airbag rear | - | ||
| Speed alert | - | ||
| Speed assist system | - | ||
| Speed sensing auto door lock | |||
| Traffic sign recognition | - | ||
| Tyre Pressure Monitoring System (TPMS) |
Safety Features
360 view camera
-
Adaptive cruise control
-
Anti-lock Braking System ABS
Anti theft alarm
-
Anti theft device
-
Automatic emergency braking
-
Blind spot collision avoidance assist
-
Blind spot monitor
-
Central locking
Cornering foglamps
-
Curtain airbag
-
Day night rear view mirror
Door ajar warning
-
Driver airbag
Driver attention warning
-
E call i call
Electronic Brakeforce Distribution EBD
Electronic Stability Control ESC
Engine immobilizer
-
Engine start alarm
-
Forward collision warning
-
Geo fence alert
-
Global NCAP Safety Rating
-
5
High beam assist
-
Hill assist
Hill descent control
-
Impact sensing auto door unlock
Isofix child seat mounts
Lane departure prevention assist
-
Lane departure warning
-
Lane keep assist
-
Leading vehicle departure alert
-
No of airbags
2
6
Oncoming lane mitigation
-
Over speeding alert
-
Parking sensors
Rear
Rear
Passenger airbag
Pretensioners force limiter seatbelts
Driver and Passenger
-
Real time vehicle tracking
-
Rear camera
Rear cross traffic alert
-
Rear cross traffic collision avoidance assist
-
Remote door lock unlock
-
Remote immobiliser
-
Road departure mitigation system
-
RSA Roadside Assistance
-
Seat belt warning
Side airbag
-
Side airbag rear
-
Speed alert
-
Speed assist system
-
Speed sensing auto door lock
Traffic sign recognition
-
Tyre Pressure Monitoring System (TPMS)
Interior Features
| Feature | MG Comet EV (Executive) | Tata Punch EV (Smart) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Additional features | Basic Audio, Bluetooth Music & Calling | ||
| Digital cluster | Embedded LCD Screen | - | |
| Dual tone dashboard | - | ||
| Leather wrap gear shift selector | - | ||
| Leather wrapped steering wheel | - | ||
| Upholstery | Fabric | Fabric |
Interior Features
Additional features
Basic Audio, Bluetooth Music & Calling
Digital cluster
Embedded LCD Screen
-
Dual tone dashboard
-
Leather wrap gear shift selector
-
Leather wrapped steering wheel
-
Upholstery
Fabric
Fabric
Comfort & Convenience
| Feature | MG Comet EV (Executive) | Tata Punch EV (Smart) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Accessory power outlet | |||
| Adjustable headrest | - | ||
| Adjustable steering | - | ||
| Air conditioner | |||
| Air quality control | - | ||
| Automatic climate control | - | ||
| Automatic headlamps | - | ||
| Cigarette lighter | - | ||
| Cooled glovebox | - | ||
| Cruise control | - | ||
| Electric adjustable seats | - | ||
| Engine start stop button | |||
| Foldable rear seat | 50:50 Split | - | |
| Follow me home headlamps | |||
| Gear shift indicator | - | ||
| Glove box | |||
| Glove box light | - | ||
| Hands free tailgate | - | ||
| Heated outside rear view mirror | - | ||
| Heater | |||
| Height adjustable driver seat | - | ||
| Keyless entry | - | ||
| Luggage hook net | |||
| Power steering | |||
| Power windows front | |||
| Rain sensing wiper | - | ||
| Rear curtain | - | ||
| Rear reading lamp | - | ||
| Rear seat centre arm rest | - | ||
| Rear seat headrest | - | ||
| Rear window sunblind | - | ||
| Rear windscreen sunblind | - | ||
| Side stepper | - | ||
| Vanity mirror | - | ||
| Ventilated seats | - |
Comfort & Convenience
Accessory power outlet
Adjustable headrest
-
Adjustable steering
-
Air conditioner
Air quality control
-
Automatic climate control
-
Automatic headlamps
-
Cigarette lighter
-
Cooled glovebox
-
Cruise control
-
Electric adjustable seats
-
Engine start stop button
Foldable rear seat
50:50 Split
-
Follow me home headlamps
Gear shift indicator
-
Glove box
Glove box light
-
Hands free tailgate
-
Heated outside rear view mirror
-
Heater
Height adjustable driver seat
-
Keyless entry
-
Luggage hook net
Power steering
Power windows front
Rain sensing wiper
-
Rear curtain
-
Rear reading lamp
-
Rear seat centre arm rest
-
Rear seat headrest
-
Rear window sunblind
-
Rear windscreen sunblind
-
Side stepper
-
Vanity mirror
-
Ventilated seats
-
Infotainment Features
| Feature | MG Comet EV (Executive) | Tata Punch EV (Smart) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Android auto | |||
| Apple carplay | |||
| Bluetooth connectivity | |||
| Digital car key | - | ||
| Digital cluster size | 7 Inch | - | |
| Digital odometer | |||
| Google alexa connectivity | - | ||
| Hinglish voice commands | - | ||
| Integrated 2din audio | - | ||
| Integrated antenna | - | ||
| Live location | - | ||
| Multi function steering wheel | - | ||
| No of speakers | 2 | - | |
| Over the air ota updates | - | ||
| Radio | |||
| Smartwatch app | |||
| Speakers | - | ||
| Touchscreen | |||
| USB Charger | Front | - | |
| USB Ports | 3 | ||
| Voice commands | - | ||
| Wi-Fi Connectivity | - | ||
| Wireless phone charging | - |
Infotainment Features
Android auto
Apple carplay
Bluetooth connectivity
Digital car key
-
Digital cluster size
7 Inch
-
Digital odometer
Google alexa connectivity
-
Hinglish voice commands
-
Integrated 2din audio
-
Integrated antenna
-
Live location
-
Multi function steering wheel
-
No of speakers
2
-
Over the air ota updates
-
Radio
Smartwatch app
Speakers
-
Touchscreen
USB Charger
Front
-
USB Ports
3
Voice commands
-
Wi-Fi Connectivity
-
Wireless phone charging
-
Select Car
Select your city
Popular Cities
